Top 10 Pizzeria in Islip

Ranked by popularity among 2 places in this category.

1. 🥇
   Mama Mia's Pizza

   📍 886 Johnson Ave Islip , NY 11779 United States

   4.0 ★★★★★ (11)
2. 🥈
   Angela's Pizza

   📍 192 Islip Ave Islip , NY 11751 United States